The All-NPSL Team was voted on by members of the media that covered the NPSL regularly during the 2016 season. Private voting took place from July 24th – July 27th. This award now includes First Team, Second Team, and Honorable Mention. Each team consists of a goalkeeper, four defenders, three midfielders, and three forwards. First Team GK Gregory Hartley, Chattanooga FC D Luke Staats, Albion SC Pros D Gabriel De Souza, Boston City FC D Chris Riordan, Clarkstown SC Eagles D Nicholas “Ebby” Lombardi, Sonoma County